Film Score Monthly
Screen Archives Entertainment 250 Golden and Silver Age Classics on CD from 1996-2013! Exclusive distribution by SCREEN ARCHIVES ENTERTAINMENT.
Sky Fighter Wild Bunch, The King Kong: The Deluxe Edition (2CD) Body Heat Friends of Eddie Coyle/Three Days of the Condor, The It's Alive Nightwatch/Killer by Night Gremlins Space Children/The Colossus of New York, The
Forgot Login?
Search Archives
Film Score Friday
Latest Edition
Previous Edition
Archive Edition
The Aisle Seat
Latest Edition
Previous Edition
Archive Edition
View Mode
Regular | Headlines
All times are PT (Pacific Time), U.S.A.
Site Map
Visits since
February 5, 2001:
© 2023 Film Score Monthly.
All Rights Reserved.
Return to Articles

Number 54

With the centennial of Bernard Herrmann’s birth on June 29th fast approaching, I thought that writing a series of blogs about him leading up to the commemoration would be a natural. Just what to write about however was the question. Herrmann is widely acknowledged as one of the giants of film music and considered by many to be the greatest of all film composers as well as the most influential. Because of such lofty distinctions, his film music has been written about endlessly over the years and much of it has been recorded time and time again. So what could I write about then that wouldn’t be just another rehash of what has been said so many times before? How about his concert works?

As a film composer, the American Herrmann stood apart from his mostly European contemporaries choosing a different approach to scoring that did not follow the long line melodies, phrases and structures of romantic and post romantic music. That style of musical composition had already been adapted to film by composers such as Max Steiner and Erich Wolfgang Korngold. Instead Herrmann, the defiant iconoclast, chose what he felt was a more effective approach that used short phrased or fragmented structures (often referred to by some as cell structures) that were tailor made for supporting the sometimes quickly shifting dynamics and edited nature of film.

Herrmann generally eschewed the use of themes as primary dramatic musical devices in film in favor of a more blocked modular approach that used orchestral texture & color, motivic & rhythmic ositinati, and precisely chosen harmonies in order to delve deeper into the psychological and emotional aspects of a film. In addition, never did he feel constrained by the need to use a standard symphony orchestra, instead choosing an ensemble of instruments that served his idea of the colors and textures that he thought best served a film’s needs. As a result Herrmann’s scores were often made up of some of the most diverse and at times seemingly bizarre groupings of musical instruments to be found in any type of music. Add to that the fact that the orchestral makeup could also change from cue to cue. This in a nutshell defines much of Herrmann’s film music style.

So what about the non-film/non-radio music he wrote for the concert hall? Quite often a composer’s concert works differ greatly from his or her film music, but in the case of Herrmann both are very similar. The harmonic language is pretty much the same (mostly tonal or modal with occasional forays into stark dissonance) and the reliance on developing varied textures and colors through orchestration is just as important. Herrmann did however make greater use of thematic material, at times using longer lined melodies and subsequently employing more development of material in his concert works. The dictates of writing to film was not a factor so there was no need for him to employ his usual shorter musical structures, although they were still a dominant trait of his compositional style. Even so, Herrmann was not primarily known as a tunesmith and his concert work, like his film work, seemed to lean heavily on orchestration, harmony and rhythmic structure to express much of the emotional and intellectual content of the music.  

Since Herrmann’s concert works are less known in general than his film music, I thought they would make a good subject for a series of centennial blogs. I’ve chosen some of his better known works and those for which recordings are available so those unfamiliar with his concert music can sample some of it and compare it to his film work if so desired. I’ll be posting a separate blog for each work over the next few months in mostly chronological order. Most of Herrmann’s concert works are from the late 1920s to the early 40’s tapering off in 1943. That seeming halt occurred as a result of his devoting all of his non-film/radio writing energies to his opera Wuthering Heights for the remainder of the 40s and into the early 50s. Even after the opera was completed in 1951 he didn't return to concert music until he wrote a few small scaled chamber works in the late 1960s.

This is the list of the concert works that will be presented in upcoming blogs:

  1. Moby Dick (1937) - Cantata
  2. Symphony (1941) -  Orchestral work
  3. The Fantasticks (1942) - Song cycle
  4. For the Fallen (1943) & Silent Noon (1935) - Orchestral works
  5. Currier and Ives Suite (1935) - Orchestral work
  6. Echoes (1965) & Souvenirs de Voyage (1967) - Chamber works

I did not include The Devil and Daniel Webster Suite (1942) or Welles Raises Kane (1943) since they are concertized works of his film music and not original concert compositions. Many are probably familiar with the music already in its original score form.

So join me in a week or so for Part 1, a presentation of Herrmann’s cantata Moby Dick.


                   The place for quotes, trivia, links, etc. 

Trivia of the week: Bernard Herrmann's father was a Russian immigrant whose last name was Dardik, a name he eventually changed to Herrmann. So this blog could have been titled "Dardik Centennial: Concert Work Series" if his father hadn't changed  the family name before Benny was born.    "Dardikesque"?!

Be seeing you...



Return to Articles Author Profile
Comments (9):Log in or register to post your own comments
Good job there, Mark. Looking forward to the rest.

P.S. Which recording are you using for the Moby cantata?

Trust it's not too early to mention that Herrmann's "Wuthering Heights" will be performed in St. Paul by the Minnesota Opera April 16 - April 23, 2011. Three hours 35 minutes, including intermission.

Good job there, Mark. Looking forward to the rest.

P.S. Which recording are you using for the Moby cantata?

Eugene, I'm using the Unicorn-Kanchana CD. I also have the old Unicorn LP, the one marred by so much distortion. Too bad the source recording both were made from had distortion issues at times.

I think I read somewhere recently that Moby Dick is set to be recorded again soon. Can anyone confirm this or have any details?

Moby Dick was recorded in Denmark for release by Chandos.

You can hear it at:

"Hør musikken til Moby Dick" (64kbps Windows Media)

Moby Dick was recorded in Denmark for release by Chandos.

You can hear it at:

"Hør musikken til Moby Dick" (64kbps Windows Media)

That must be the new recording I heard about. Thanks Jonathan!

Awesome news!

Mark, I'm just now catching up on your series on Herrmann's concert works and I am so pleased that you are doing this! I've just written a comment on your Moby Dick review as well, but wanted to congratulate and thank you here as well. I look forward to reading your enthusiastic thoughts on the rest of the works!

For those interested in Moby Dick, as Joe Sikoryak mentioned in the comments for Mark's blog review of that work, I will be conducting the west coast premiere of Moby Dick, and the first US performances of the work since its 1940 premiere. Yes, the Chandos CD will be released later, but here is a chance locally (well, in California - at least within the US) to hear the work live - and I suspect it may win more followers in a live setting that captures the immediate drama of the piece.

Keep 'em coming, Mark! I hope we can chat some time about Herrmann - I love your enthusiasm for his music, particular the concert works which tend to be ignored.

Keep 'em coming, Mark! I hope we can chat some time about Herrmann - I love your enthusiasm for his music, particular the concert works which tend to be ignored.

John, have you ever hooked up with Bill Stromberg and John Morgan to talk Herrmann? As I'm sure you know they're both devoted keepers of the Herrmann flame. I know Bill just conducted FOR THE FALLEN at a concert a couple of weeks ago. Bill talks a bit about it in this thread:

Hello Mark! I have yet to intersect with Stromberg and Morgan, though I have long admired their meticulous and devoted work. It's strange - as a conductor I have been mostly in the realm of orchestral and opera work, and not film. It has long been my intention to integrate film score suites into standard orchestral repertoire (if we program incidental music like Peer Gynt, or ballet suites by Tchaikovsky, Prokofiev etc, then why not suites from films? why must it be seen as "pops" concert fare?), though I'm waiting for the right opportunity to start doing so. But as one who is not as involved in the film world, except as an area of much research, I'm only just making friends in that field. At some point, I would love to be involved in some of these re-recording projects, the way that Stromberg and McNeely have been doing. I'm sure at some point that will happen, and look forward to that. I would especially like to record all of the concert works, as I'm very fond of them all. I have been looking into some of the earlier concert works that no one has recorded yet, too. Herrmann was so familiar with so many other composers' works, and it is fascinating to hear certain influences from Ives, Delius, Grainger, Stravinsky, etc in his early works (and in all the rest of his music too!). But... I start to digress and ramble enthusiastically... :-)

Film Score Monthly Online
The Marvels Project, Part 1
Orton and The Holdovers
Monsieur John Williams
Lessons in Melody
Musical Dicks
Pinar Patrol
The Rostam Version
Wong's Turn: 2023 Holiday Gift Guide
Reviving The Lords of the Fallen
Raiders in Concert in Ireland
My Love Affair With Music
Ear of the Month Contest: Joe Hisaishi
Today in Film Score History:
December 5
Cliff Eidelman born (1964)
Dave Brubeck died (2012)
Jerry Goldsmith begins recording his score to Coma (1977)
Jerry Goldsmith records his score for the Room 222 pilot (1968)
John Altman born (1949)
Johnny Pate born (1923)
Karl-Ernst Sasse born (1923)
Manuel De Sica died (2014)
Masaru Sato died (1999)
Osvaldo Golijov born (1960)
Richard Gibbs born (1955)
Ron Jones records his score for the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode "The Outrageous Okona" (1988)
FSMO Featured Video
Video Archive • Audio Archive
© 2023 Film Score Monthly. All Rights Reserved.
Website maintained and powered by Veraprise and Matrimont.